Wax-ring-vs-rubber, if you’re installing a new toilet or replacing a broken seal, there are a couple of options for a new toilet seal. traditionally plumbers have used wax rings, but there are new mess-free options on the market as an alternative.. Traditionally, toilets use wax rings to create an airtight seal between the floor and the toilet. in the past, if you needed to repair or replace a toilet seal, you’d only have the choice of installing another wax ring. now, thanks to new products on the market, you have another choice. keep reading to learn …, the 7530p8 "better than wax, waxfree toilet bowl gasket" is one of the main rubber seals on the market, and it really is a great product. this was my first experience with waxless, and the installation is actually extremely simple, and has no mess..

Some toilet seals are made from rubber, but wax is arguably the most popular material. wax has been used for toilet seals for a long time, and for a good reason. wax is malleable and adjusts well to the weight of the toilet, creating a super tight seal. however, wax-free seals are also famous for various reasons such as cleanliness and durability., wax-free toilet rings are becoming more popular because they don’t require the same clean up as a waxy substance and they tend to last longer. a rubber toilet ring should provide an adequate seal but doesn’t conform to pressure like wax does (wax tends to melt around the to ends which creates the seal)..

Personally, i'll take a good ol fashioned wax ring anyday. i also don't really like the horned donuts. i prefer a plain ol wax ring, unless the closet flange is slightly below the floor height for some reason, installed poorly or new tile height, then i might go for the horned., how tall the ring is depends on how close the toilet's outlet horn is to the flange. under ideal conditions, the standard ring is just a bit too tall so that it compresses just enough to form a good seal without squeezing out into the drainage path and causing an obstruction..

I prefer wax over the wax-free. when you install/replace a toilet, it should be a permanent scenario. from a service perspective, i've been the lucky guy to financially prosper from horned wax rings or those new fluidmaster waxless adaptors that jar loose during install, and leak.